West of England Regional Qualifiers

9th March 2008

Adjudicators Comments

.................................................................................................................................................................................................

Alan Hope

I. Good opening, detail generally good. 3 - nice s.c. good attention to dynamics. 8+5 so tidy. 9 - good marcato. 11 bass detail? 12 Troms superb. This has got good dynamic control. Nice contrasts 16 - 17+2. Close neat.

II. Beautiful opening and dynamic control superb. 1 Again troms and basses impressive. Euph shines and accompaniments sympathetic. 2 Refined playing. 3 Sop and horn so complimentary to each other and flow. Lovely spaced horns before 5. 5+5 well balanced. 6 Passionate indeed and 7 nice in contrast. 8 Wow - superb. 9 Did not feel con moto. 10+5 good section this. 11 Troms stylish! Ending well worked.

III. Stylish and rhythmical. 2 - dainty to 5. 5 - an excellent pp. 8 Again has space for all to shine with the phrasing. 10 Moves off so clearly. 11 - very effective to a superb ending.

A very good performance - very shaped and balanced.
Soloists superb and all well directed.
Thank you.

Colin Hardy

I. Fluent start which flows with balanced style. 4 plus lots of control. 6 + again good dynamic contrasts, lots of space. 9 good marcato. 11 a touch untidy but soon picks up. 13 great p and build up is good. 15 controlled and all flows to conclusion.

II. This is stylish with great contrast. 1 bass's a touch overdone for me. 1+5 Euph links well. 2 Stylish cornet as is Flug. 3 links well but hn a touch loose but overall good. 4 + pk. This is so musical. 5+ just enjoying. 6 good contrasts. 7 well in control. 8 also. 9 I could take more con moto here. 10 again in control. 11 nice contrast and remains secure to close.

III. Lovely shape. 2 ok just rushes a shade, bar 4 untidy. Flow to 5 then great pp section and flows lovely to dim into 8 - this is very musical. Well done Soloists. 10 This is so detailed. 11 Wow, it flows with detail and a neat close.

Very good performance with lots of musical shape. Just odd slips but super show.
Many Thanks.

.................................................................................................................................................................................................